Would the Original Star Wars Trilogy Staff Make Better Sequels?

Imagine if the creative minds behind the original Star Wars trilogy—Lucasfilm, George Lucas, and the crew—were tasked with crafting the sequel trilogy. How would their vision transform the series, and would we see an improvement over the actual sequels released over the years?

Combining Forces: The Potential Synergy

If you look at the talented team that brought us the original movies, it’s hard to deny the potential for greatness. Scott Reynolds and Lawrence Kasdan, known for their immense contribution to the original trilogy, would have been essential in ensuring the narrative consistency and depth of plot that fans crave. Additionally, with the long-time involvement of Kathleen Kennedy and Lucas yourself directing, the special effects would have no doubt reached new heights.

In fact, with George Lucas at the helm as a director, the special effects could have been cutting-edge, enriching the visual storytelling to an unprecedented level. Instead, elements like light saber duels would have been brought to new life, elevating the action and spectacle.

Kathleen Kennedy, a well-respected editor, would have been instrumental in refining and enhancing the storylines while ensuring a coherent narrative arc. Her expertise in story editing would have resulted in a more polished and engaging cinematic experience.

And let’s not forget about Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, and Harrison Ford bearing the burden of rounding out the narrative with their well-developed characters. The acting would have been nothing short of legendary, combining the charisma and rugged appeal that made the original characters so beloved.

The Question of Continuity and Innovation

Would a collaboration between these familiar faces have resulted in a series that diverged from the original trajectory, or would it have creatively maintained the familiar elements while still pushing the boundaries? The answer might lie in a combination of both.

Some might argue that George Lucas’s vision for the sequels, which included villains like Darth Maul, could have been realized in a way that respected the expanded universe (EU) while still introducing fresh, engaging plotlines. This mix of continuity and innovation could have resulted in a franchise that felt both fan-friendly and thrillingly new.

Moreover, the original trilogy’s adherence to its own universe and mythology would have been paramount. The sequels might have followed suit, incorporating the elements that made the series so iconic—whether it be the political maneuvering of the Galactic Senate, the intrigue of imperial power, or the hero’s journey of Rey and Kylo Ren.

Conclusion: A New Dawn for Star Wars

Ultimately, the collaboration between the original trilogy’s key figures could have led to a new era of Star Wars that was both respectful of its heritage and bold in its innovation. While it’s impossible to know for certain what would have transpired, it is safe to say that the resulting films would likely have been of higher quality and more enjoyable for fans.

Let’s also consider the impact on the digital age. Imagine if the special effects and storytelling had been reimagined, and the onboard potential of the sequels had been fully realized. The series might have taken a significant leap forward in both technical and narrative terms, potentially leading to a more cohesive and compelling saga.

So, while the actual sequels faced significant criticism and backlash, the sheer potential of the original staff’s collaboration could have given us a series that not only met but perhaps even surpassed our expectations.