Would You Want a Modern-Day Wizarding World with Known Characters?
For longtime Harry Potter aficionados, the idea of a new game set in the present-day Wizarding World is intriguing. Some fans, such as those who have just recently entered the fandom or are young enthusiasts, might be overjoyed at the prospect of an experience as exciting as Hogwarts Legacy, now with a contemporary twist. But is a modern-day Hogwarts with characters like Headmistress McGonagall, Professor Longbottom, and Professor Scamander really what the Harry Potter universe needs?
The Pros and Cons of a Modern-Day Wizarding World
The Harry Potter universe is filled with iconic locations and beloved characters that have made it a beloved franchise. However, wagging a finger at Lonely Planet, some argue that Hogwarts is like Tatooine - a great setting with countless fascinating stories, but a little too saturated.
Dean Potter believes that reimagining the Witching World in a more contemporary setting could offer fresh stories and new experiences. If you've grown tired of exploring the castle and its nooks and crannies, perhaps a game focusing on the Ministry of Magic could provide a different kind of adventure. Imagine the thrill of being an Auror, Cursebreaker, or an Unspeakable, embarking on quests to hunt Dark Wizards and solve mysteries in a vast open world.
Arguments Against a Modern-Day Setting
Others, like Jane Doe, wonder if the Wizarding World feels more authentic in the past. For them, the 19th century or even earlier might suit the narrative better. The real question is, would the original characters from the seven books accurately portray their personas in a modern setting? Fear not, some fans still dream of seeing old-time characters in a contemporary setting. However, the challenge lies in maintaining the believable authenticity of these characters.
Renting a Modern Hogwarts
Some readers are excited at the idea of seeing how modern technologies would blend with the familiar wizarding world. Imagine magical practices that incorporate everyday gadgets, spells cast with mobile apps, and a world where Muggles are more integrated. The possibilities are endless, and the experience could be exceptional. Instead of being stuck in the same old locations, fans could explore a dynamic and evolving Wizarding World.
The Sceptics: A Game Without True Storylines
But what about the sceptics? For some, the idea of a new game may be appealing, but adding modern characters and technologies alone might not be enough if the storyline lacks depth. The absence of iconic events, like the return of Voldemort, can make the game seem stale. Moreover, the reimagining of beloved characters could lead to a clash with fans' cherished memories and lore.
Hotly contested, the debate continues: would a modern-day Hogwarts Legacy offer true magic or fall flat due to an over-reliance on nostalgia?