The Untold Story: Rock N Roll's Missing Legends Why They Deserve Inclusion in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame
When we think of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, it's often seen as a hallowed ground where history is written and artists are immortalized. However, it can be argued that many influential rock artists who shaped the genre in the 1970s have been overlooked, overshadowed, or even deliberately omitted from its esteemed ranks. This article delves into the stories of some of these notable artists, exploring why they deserve a place in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
Why The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Matters
Let's start with the premise that the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (R/R) is not merely a sanctuary for rock enthusiasts but a symbolic representation of the cultural heritage of rock music. Created in 1983, its mission is to honor and preserve the legacy of artists who have significantly impacted the rock genre. However, like most institutions, the R/R is susceptible to subjective biases and corporate interests that can influence selections.
Some critics argue that the R/R is a tool in the hands of those who want to curate a version of rock history that aligns with their personal or corporate interests. They suggest that the process for inducting artists is opaque and overly influenced by financial metrics, rather than artistic merit. If self-appointed entities are determining the significance of art, it can be argued that the general public is being shortchanged.
Aesthetic Appreciation: The Subjectivity of Merit
The aesthetic appreciation of art is inherently subjective. While financial success is typically not the only criterion for artistic excellence, it is often one of the most visible criteria used in selecting inductees. When an institution like the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame relies on such metrics, it risks excluding talented artists who did not achieve immediate fame or fortune but made significant contributions to the genre.
Some 1970s Rock Legends Not Yet Inducted
Bette Midler and Olivia Newton-John
Bette Midler and Olivia Newton-John, both powerful and influential voices of the 1970s, are notable artists who have yet to find their place in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Bette Midler's unique blend of humor, rock, and cabaret resonated with audiences during a time when musical styles were evolving rapidly. Olivia Newton-John, known for hits like "Physical," set new standards for crossover success between rock and pop, particularly during the disco era.
The J Geils Band and Boston
The J Geils Band and Boston, both masters of hard rock and blues-rock, have left a lasting legacy in the rock community. These bands, while achieving significant popularity, have fallen just short of being inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Their influence on the genre and contributions to the rock sound cannot be ignored, and their omission from the hall is a testament to the selective nature of inclusions.
Janis Ian and Bob Welch
Janis Ian, a pioneering songwriter and performer, and Bob Welch, a talented guitarist known for his work with Fleetwood Mac, have both had significant impacts on the rock landscape. Yet, they remain entities on the periphery of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. These influential artists deserve recognition for their innovative contributions to rock music.
The Inclusive Case for Induction
The argument for inducting these artists rests on the premise that inclusivity is essential for a true representation of the genre's history. Induction does not only honor the artist's legacy but also serves as a public declaration of the artistic value of their work. By overlooking these artists, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame risks perpetuating an incomplete and biased narrative of rock history.
Moreover, induction would serve to celebrate the diversity within the genre, acknowledging that rock music is far more than just hit singles and album sales. It encompasses a wide range of styles, eras, and cultural impacts. Recognizing the contributions of these artists would provide a more comprehensive and accurate portrayal of the genre's evolution.
Conclusion
While some may argue that the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is a corporate construct, it remains a valuable institution for preserving the history and legacy of rock music. It is essential to have candid discussions about who gets recognized and why. By broadening the criteria for selection and acknowledging all significant contributors, we can ensure that the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame truly represents the full spectrum of rock music's rich and diverse heritage.