The Oath and Its Consequences: What If Fingolfin Slew Morgoth Without the Silmarils?
The legendarium of Middle-earth, as meticulously crafted by J.R.R. Tolkien, is a rich tapestry of mythical narratives and the intricate ties that bind its inhabitants. One intriguing contemplation hinges on the scenario where Fingolfin, the High King of the Noldor, slays Morgoth in single combat without obtaining the Silmarils. This article explores the potential ramifications of such an event, focusing on the unwavering oath sworn by the Sons of F?anor and the inevitable course of events that would unfold.
The Power and Responsibility of the Silmarils
The Silmarils, among the most acclaimed jewels in Arda's storied history, hold a dual curse and blessing. Possession of these shimmering treasures has led to countless conflicts and disasters. Fingolfin, being another high-profile Noldorin elf, would face a unique situation if he slew Morgoth without the Silmarils.
Had Fingolfin defeated Morgoth, he would be hailed as a hero of the ages. The epic battle alone would earn him monumental respect and acclaim. His actions would not be marred by the complex history of the Silmarils, making him a pure hero in the eyes of the Noldor, especially those of the corrupted Sons of F?anor.
The Sons of F?anor: Bound by Oath
The oath sworn by the Sons of F?anor, a pivotal element in their history, demonstrates the ironclad commitment and devotion they maintain towards their ancestors' relics. The oath is as solemn and irrevocable as the ones made by kings to gods. It is unaltered, unnegotiable, and absolute.
The oath begins with the declaration that neither law nor love, nor any form of defense, no matter how formidable, can protect the bearer of a Silmaril from F?anor and his kin. It continues with the assurance that the Sons of F?anor will deal death to whosoever hides, hoards, or takes one. The oath is harsh and uncompromising, leaving no room for reprieve or redemption.
Even if the Silmarils themselves burn those who possess them, the oath stands firm. Fingolfin, despite being their uncle, would be no exception. This unforgiving vow leaves the Sons of F?anor with no choice but to remain true to their word, regardless of the pain or consequences that may follow.
The Unavoidable Consequences
Once the Sons of F?anor regain the Silmarils, despite the fact that Fingolfin's actions may have liberated them from what they perceived as a curse, their oath remains unbroken. The possession of the Silmarils, whether burnt or not, would subject them to the consequences outlined in their solemn vow. They would be bound to hunt and kill Fingolfin, fulfilling the oaths made to Ernil Illuvatar, the Creator of all things.
Moreover, Fingolfin, despite his heroism, might find himself in a precarious position if the Silmarils burn his hands. The pledge of the Sons of F?anor is not easily dismissed. The bloodstain from the first Kinslaying and Fingolfin's hesitance to retreat to Valinor after the Nirnaeth Arnoediad (the Unnumbered Tears) might further incriminate him in their eyes. These factors, combined with the unbreakable oath, would ensure that his path to peace is fraught with dangers and challenges.
Conclusion
The scenario of Fingolfin slaying Morgoth without the Silmarils presents a compelling yet complex narrative within the world of Middle-earth. While Fingolfin would be a revered hero, the Sons of F?anor would remain bound by their unwavering oaths. The path to honor and redemption for both sides would be paved with challenges, demonstrating the profound impact of oaths and the unyielding nature of the Silmarils in the contexts of Tolkien's works.