The Consistency in Rookie K-Pop Groups: Vocal Pre-Recording or Aesthetic Uniformity?

Whenever a new rookie K-pop group hits the charts, a recurring theme of scrutiny emerges—do these performances sound the same or simply similar in style? This article aims to delve into the prevalent notion that rookie groups' performances often sound alike and the common practice of vocal pre-recording. Is it just a perception or a reality backed by the industry's common practices?

Sounding Alike: The Case of Aespas vs. RedVelvet

Let's start with a specific comparison. A reader has noted that Aespas' performances, while praising their lead vocalist Ningning's high notes, do indeed bear a resemblance to RedVelvet's hit song 'Psycho.' The chorus is particularly striking, making one wonder if it sounds slightly familiar. While individual vocal performances may vary, the overall consistency in style and sound can be striking.

This observation is not unique. Many fans point out that not just Aespas, but rookie groups in general, tend to have a uniform sound. This similarity has fueled discussions and hypotheses, with some wondering if the consistency is due to pre-recorded vocals, pre-produced dances, or a combination of both.

The Role of Pre-Recording in Rookie Performances

One of the most common practices among rookie groups in the K-pop industry is the use of pre-recorded vocals. This process is widely accepted and acknowledged as a significant factor in ensuring performances meet high standards of quality and consistency. Pre-recorded vocals allow for meticulous editing, perfecting of notes, and alignment of the vocal performance with the dance moves and music video footage. This technique is particularly common in the early stages of a group's career, when live performances may still be developing.

For instance, Ningning's delivery of high notes in Aespas' performance is indeed impressive. However, when she was required to sing the same track live on Inkigayo, there was a noticeable difference in her vocal performance. Her voice did not reach the same height as in the pre-recorded version, and she exhibited signs of shakiness. This observation supports the notion that even when the group's style remains consistent, pre-recorded vocals play a crucial role in delivering polished performances.

Live Versus Pre-Recorded: Which Performance is Better?

The choice between live and pre-recorded performances is often a matter of personal preference. Some fans enjoy the raw energy and authenticity of live performances, while others prefer the precision and quality of pre-recorded tracks. It's important to note that both methods have their advantages and disadvantages:

Live Performances: Offer spontaneity, energy, and an immediate connection with the audience. Fans can witness the group's growth and improvement over time. Pre-Recorded Performances: Ensure consistency, perfection, and a polished final product. These performances are often more aligned with the group's aesthetic and can be used in promotions and music videos.

Ultimately, the debate between live and pre-recorded performances reflects the broader conversation about the role of authenticity versus perfection in the K-pop industry. While some argue that live performances should be prioritized for building a genuine fanbase, others appreciate the flawless quality that pre-recorded versions provide.

Conclusion and Future Prospects

The consistency in rookie K-pop groups' performances, while often criticized, is a result of both industry standards and the early stages of a group's development. Vocal pre-recording is a widely accepted practice that helps ensure high-quality, polished performances. As these groups grow and gain more experience, they often move towards more live performances, which can provide a natural transition for fans.

Whether the sound is consistent due to pre-recording or a deliberate aesthetic choice remains a topic of debate. Fans and observers alike can appreciate the efforts put into creating well-polished performances while also hoping that these groups continue to evolve and develop their unique sound.