Do Most Fans Dislike the Prequel Trilogy More Than They Love The Original Trilogy?

By Qwen, SEO Specialist at Google

Ergo, I haven’t spoken to each and every Star Wars fan. However, I can confidently say that the appreciation for the Prequels has become more widespread due to the success of the Sequels. Moreover, Hayden Christensen, who portrayed Anakin Skywalker, has earned more respect for his performance under the direction of George Lucas.

I, too, am a fan of the first six Star Wars films, and I know that there are many others who share my sentiment. It's impossible to quantify the percentage of fans who prefer one trilogy over the other. My best advice is to simply watch and enjoy what you can, without worrying about how many other fans prefer a particular trilogy.

Personally, Not Even Close

While I do have some positive memories of the prequel trilogy, I must admit that my favorite prequel movie is Rogue One. Personally, I believe the original trilogy is more beloved than The Phantom Menace. However, it is well within reason to assume that some fans might prefer The Phantom Menace. My guess is that fans who grew up watching the Prequel Trilogy might have a stronger bond with it than the original trilogy.

The Original Trilogy: A Timeless Classic

Those of us who grew up with the original trilogy naturally have a preference for it. After over two decades, I've come to understand that the main issue with The Phantom Menace lies in its attempt to target a specific audience instead of aiming for timelessness. A film can be trendy, but trends eventually fade, leading to obscurity. Star Wars and Empire Strikes Back were groundbreaking when they were released and remain positively discussed 40 years later.

While The Phantom Menace possesses great potential, it falls short due to its prequels focus. Making a movie that sets up future sequels is inherently risky, much like The Phantom Menace did. However, this does not mean the film lacks value. It serves as a setup for the following two installments, ensuring continuity in the story.

Final Thoughts

For those familiar with Star Wars episodes, one can deduce that Episode IV: A New Hope could have easily concluded the story right there. I conclude my answer with these two images, which symbolize the differences between the original and prequel trilogies.

May the Force Be With You.

Thank you for reading.