Do Hospitals Call the Police on Patients Leaving Against Medical Advice? Debunking the Myth

The question of whether hospitals call the police on patients who refuse treatment and leave against medical advice (AMA) is a common concern. In the UK, as is the case in many other countries, hospitals enforce careful policies to ensure patient safety while respecting patient autonomy.

UK Hospital Policies and Procedures

In the UK, when a patient refuses treatment, medical professionals will explain the benefits and potential risks of their actions. Patients leaving against medical advice are often asked to sign a disclaimer, acknowledging the consequences of their actions. However, if a patient is deemed incapable of making an informed decision due to mental incapacity, steps are taken to ensure their safety.

Medical Decisions and Patient Autonomy

Doctors in the UK are required to weigh the patient's wishes against the potential risks of leaving against medical advice. If a patient is deemed to be at risk of harm, they may be kept for further observation or admitted to a psychiatric ward for a safety assessment. These measures aim to balance respect for patient autonomy with the need to ensure patient safety.

Community and Legal Actions

In many cases, community professionals might drive by the patient's house to check on their well-being. This is more common for non-clinical scenarios such as a patient leaving with items from the hospital. However, if the patient's behavior poses a safety threat, the hospital staff may contact the police for assistance.

Personal Experiences and Activism

I have had personal experiences with leaving against medical advice. In May of this year, I was in the ER with severe abdominal pain. Despite the ER doctor's dismissive attitude, I managed to get the necessary tests run. When the doctor refused to discharge me and insisted I needed one more test, I politely but firmly left without signing a disclaimer.

Unfortunately, my near-fatal infections in the subsequent months highlight how crucial it is to follow medical advice. Being an activist, I understand the pressures faced by healthcare professionals and the importance of patient respect and autonomy.

Behaviors Leading to Police Involvement

Hospitals might call the police if a patient's behavior creates an immediate safety threat. This could include verbal threats, physical aggression, or any other actions that endanger themselves or others. In such cases, the police are contacted for assistance in ensuring everyone's safety.

Conclusion

The myth of hospitals calling the police on all patients who leave against medical advice is a misleading generalization. The decision to involve law enforcement is based on the specific circumstances and potential safety risks. Understanding the complexities involved can help bridge the gap between patient autonomy and hospital protocols.

For more information on hospital policies and patient rights, refer to the relevant healthcare organizations and legal frameworks in your region.