Did Rhaegar Targaryen Secretly Have Children with Elia Martell?

One of the most intriguing questions in the world of Game of Thrones pertains to whether Rhaegar Targaryen actually had children with Elia Martell. Let’s delve into the facts and explore the controversial topic in detail.

Genealogical and Historical Background

For context, it is important to note the complex relationships and family dynamics within the Targaryen and Martell families. Initially, Rhaegar Targaryen was married to Rhaella Targaryen, the sister of Aerys II Targaryen, and they had three living children: Rhaegar, Viserys, and Daenerys. However, Rhaella suffered several miscarriages and stillbirths, indicating that her health may have been compromised.

Second Marriage and Children with Elia Martell

After Rhaegar’s marriage to Rhaella, he married Elia Martell, sister to Omont and Meryn Martell of Dorne. Together, they had two children: a daughter named Rhaenys and a son named Aegon. Rhaegar’s second marriage was publicly acknowledged, and this naturally raised the question of whether the children were his true offspring.

The Feasibility of the Secret Fatherhood

Given the authenticity of Rhaegar and Elia’s marriage, it’s unlikely that he would have had a secret relationship with her. Additionally, the likelihood that Aerys II Targaryen, Rhaegar’s father, and Elia Martell’s sister (Omont) would not have approved a union that could potentially produce Targaryen offspring is high.

Medical and Physical Conditions of Elia Martell

Elia Martell was known to be sickly and physically weak, making her pregnancy challenging. In her last pregnancy, which resulted in Aegon, her condition worsened. It’s possible that these health issues prevented her from conceiving again. Given these circumstances, the secret fatherhood argument faces significant challenges.

Controversies and Speculations

Speculations about Aerys II Targaryen potentially raping Elia Martell, which would have been a motive for a secret relationship and children, are highly unlikely based on the character’s traits and historical behavior. Moreover, Aerys II showed disdain toward Elia and her daughter Rhaenys, suggesting he would have worked to prevent any offspring.

Conclusion: Public Announcement and Public Recognition

The fact that Rhaegar and Elia’s marriage was publicly announced, and the birth of their children were celebrated, indicates that there was no significant secrecy. Families in Westeros, especially nobility, typically made such announcements to preserve their lineages and claim to the throne.

Therefore, based on the known historical facts and the public records of the times, it is highly improbable that Rhaegar Targaryen had secret children with Elia Martell. The birth of the children was well-documented and celebrated, thereby making their parentage openly known.