How Good is Torchwood in the Realm of Doctor Who?

Torchwood is often considered more of a dark and disturbing parallel to the beloved series Doctor Who. It explores the worst and most terrifying phenomena that traverse to Earth and wreak havoc on humanity. The show delves into mature themes, particularly in its portrayal of relationships, making it considerably more adult-oriented than its counterpart.

Season Review: From Episodic Episodes to Breathtaking Arcs

While the first two seasons of Torchwood adhere to a more episodic and minor arc format, providing a steady but not overly complex storyline, the third season, titled Children of Earth, takes a significant leap in quality and depth. This season is widely regarded as an incredible achievement in the series, blending thrilling narratives with cutting-edge science fiction elements. The episode count, however, can be seen as a drawback. Despite its overall brilliance, Children of Earth feels slightly stretched over more episodes than necessary, probably under 10, possibly closer to 5 or 6 episodes for optimal impact.

Comparisons with Other Series: Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes

It's interesting to compare Torchwood with its predecessor Life on Mars (LoM) and its sequel, Ashes to Ashes (AtA). Both series, like Torchwood, are part of a delving into the supernatural and the science fiction genre, but they differentiate themselves in significant ways. LoM is a fine blend of a police procedural narrative with rich and immersive fictional elements.

Unlike Torchwood, LoM is not strictly defined as a science fiction show, although it certainly benefits from such classification. What truly sets LoM apart is its extended story arc, where characters evolve and develop over time. This continuity is a clear differentiation between Torchwood, which tends to be more episodic and less continuous in its storytelling approach, particularly in the first two seasons.

The Verdict: Which Show is Superior?

My personal view leans more towards the idea that Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes are more sophisticated shows than Torchwood. These series offer a richer, more nuanced exploration of themes, character development, and storytelling. Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes are not just about horror and science fiction; they delve into the human condition in a manner that is both poignant and thought-provoking. However, it is important to acknowledge that opinion is subjective, and your personal preference may vary. The beauty of television lies in its ability to cater to a wide range of interests and styles.

Conclusion

While Torchwood has its merits, particularly in its haunting third season, Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes stand out for their sophisticated storytelling and character development. Both series are compelling and worthy of watching, but Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes provide a deeper, more nuanced viewing experience. Each show offers a unique exploration of the human condition within the vast and ever-evolving realm of science fiction and television drama.